This brings us up to date with the review of big calls affecting the top two in the SPFL.
08/11/26 St Mirren vs The Rangers
Incident 1
Referee: Nick Walsh
Game Minute: 17th
Score At Time: 0-0
Incident: Penrice goes down in the box
Outcome: Penalty to TRFC
Evidence:
Yorkshire Whistler Verdict:
IOD: Penalty to Rangers
Penrice breaks into the box and commits the defender into making a challenge.
The contact looks minimal, but the ref is well positioned at the time and gives the foul & penalty. Upon watching the replays, the contact is negligible but there does appear to be a slight touch from left foot of the defender onto the outer left foot of Penrice. This could be enough to knock him off balance.
Certainly a ‘soft’ foul, but once the contact is identified on the replay, you cannot definitively say it was a wrong call.
Verdict: CORRECT decision.
Expected Points Outcome: No impact
09/11/26 Celtic vs Kilmarnock
Incident 1
Referee: John Beaton
Game Minute: 13th
Score At Time: 0-0
Incident: Hogh scores for Celtic
Outcome: Goal to Celtic overturned on VAR review for foul by Baur
Evidence:
At 0:30
Yorkshire Whistler Verdict:
IOD: Goal to Celtic overturned by VAR for a foul by Baur
Unfortunately for Celtic, this goal is ruled out for a foul in the build-up. Baur’s left foot just clips his opponent’s right leg without playing the ball. This contact allows the Celtic man to turn over possession, which then leads to the goal.
Upon replay, there is a foul committed here and so the free kick is rightly awarded and the goal ruled out.
Verdict: CORRECT decision.
Incident 2
Referee: John Beaton
Game Minute: 73rd
Score At Time: 1-0
Incident: Tshibola blocks a shot
Outcome: Free kick to Celtic for handball overturned to penalty
Evidence:
At 2:15
Yorkshire Whistler Verdict:
IOD: Free kick to Celtic for handball overturned to a penalty.
The defender goes to block a shot and turns his back on the ball. In doing so he always twist his right arm out in an unnatural position, and it is this part of the body, that the ball then strikes.
I would agree this an accidental hand ball offence, that is punishable as an infringement. In real time, it is difficult to tell if this handball contact happens outside or inside the penalty area. VAR feels it is directly on the line, which means it is correctly upgraded to a penalty kick.
Verdict: CORRECT decision.
Expected Points Outcome: No impact.
Summary
My thanks, as always, to the Yorkshire Whistler.
Another clean week for the officials as we continue with the international break.
With no new wrongly impactful decisions this time out the situation remains:

So far Celtic are estimated to have lost 1.14 points from refereeing errors and The Rangers benefitted by 0.46 points. A difference of 1.6 expected points in The Rangers favour.
After 13 matches for Celtic and 12 for The Rangers, Celtic leads The Rangers by four points.



